As a seasoned financial advisor, I’ve spent years helping individuals understand the nutty world of investments and retirement planning. Throughout my career, I’ve observed that even the most rational investors can fall prey to behavioral biases that significantly impact their financial decisions.
Understanding and managing these biases are important for reaching your long-term financial objectives. In this blog post, we will examine nine prevalent behavioral biases in investment decision-making and offer strategies to help you steer clear of their pitfalls.
What Are Behavioral Biases In Investment Decision-Making?
Behavioral biases are consistent tendencies to deviate from rational judgment, influencing your investment decisions. These biases are rooted in human psychology and can lead to irrational behaviors that can hugely impact what your financial situation looks like down the line.
Thankfully, the field of behavioral finance has identified several common biases that influence investor behavior. By recognizing these biases, you can create strategies to counteract them, which can positively impact the overall performance of your portfolio.
Please Note: Understanding the overall psychology that influences the market can be incredibly beneficial for investors. If you’re interested in exploring this topic further, we have an article on how human emotions and faulty thinking can drive the patterns we see repeatedly in the market.
1) Overconfidence Bias
Overconfidence bias is when investors overly trust their own knowledge, skills, and the precision of their forecasts. This can lead to taking excessive risks and making poor investment choices. Here are some important considerations regarding overconfidence bias:
Examples of Overconfidence in Investment Decisions: Investors might believe they can consistently pick winning stocks or time the market accurately (or get in touch with an “expert” or “guru” that can). This overconfidence can lead to frequent trading, which increases transaction costs and may result in lower overall returns. For instance, an investor might be confident about a stock’s future performance after conducting minimal research, only to experience substantial losses when the stock does not perform as expected.
Impact on Investment Outcomes: Overconfidence can result in under-diversification, where an investor places too much capital into a few high-risk investments. This lack of diversification increases the risk of substantial losses. Additionally, overconfident investors may ignore critical market signals, leading to missed opportunities or poor timing in buying and selling assets.
Strategies to Mitigate Overconfidence: To combat overconfidence, it’s important to maintain a diversified portfolio that spreads risk across different asset classes. Seeking feedback from financial advisors or peers can provide alternative perspectives and reduce the chances of making decisions based solely on personal conviction. Additionally, relying on data-driven decision-making, such as historical performance data and market analysis, rather than gut feelings, can help in making more rational investment choices.
2) Anchoring Bias
Anchoring bias happens when investors place too much importance on a specific piece of information (i.e. an “anchor”) when making choices. This reliance can distort their judgment and result in far-from-ideal outcomes. Here are some ways anchoring bias influences investments:
How Anchoring Influences Investment Decisions: Investors might overly focus on a stock’s purchasing price and base their decisions on this anchor rather than current market conditions. For example, an investor who buys a stock at $65 might hold onto it despite market indicators suggesting a sell, because they are fixated on the initial purchase price.
Examples of Anchoring in the Financial Markets: During market downturns, investors may hold onto losing stocks longer, hoping to sell them at the initial purchase price they paid, rather than considering the stock’s current and future potential. This behavior can lead to missed opportunities to cut losses and reinvest in more promising assets.
Tips to Avoid Anchoring Bias: Avoid making decisions based solely on past prices or initial impressions. Instead, focus on the intrinsic value of investments and broader market trends. Setting predefined criteria for selling investments, regardless of their purchase price, can also help mitigate the effects of anchoring bias.
3) Confirmation Bias
Confirmation bias is the inclination to seek out, interpret, and recall information that supports one’s preexisting beliefs. This can result in overlooking evidence that challenges those beliefs. Here’s how confirmation bias can impact your portfolio:
The Role of Confirmation Bias in Investment Decisions: Investors may focus on positive news about their favorite stocks while disregarding negative information. This selective attention can result in an overly optimistic view of an investment’s potential and can prevent investors from making balanced and informed decisions.
Examples of Confirmation Bias Affecting Investors: An investor might only read reports and articles that support their bullish outlook on a particular stock, ignoring warning signs or negative analyses. For instance, if an investor believes in the growth potential of a tech company, they may overlook signs of declining market share or increased competition.
Ways to Counteract Confirmation Bias: To manage confirmation bias, actively seek out diverse perspectives and opinions, especially those that challenge your views. Engage with contrarian viewpoints and consider the merits of arguments that differ from your own. Additionally, relying on a systematic investment process that includes regular reviews and objective analysis can help ensure that decisions are based on comprehensive information rather than selective confirmation.
4) Herding Bias
Herding bias refers to the tendency of investors to follow the crowd, mimicking the actions of what you believe everyone else is doing. This behavior can lead to market bubbles and crashes. Here’s how herding bias can rear its ugly head in your investments:
How Herding Behavior Manifests in Financial Markets: Investors may buy into hot stocks because everyone else is, without considering the underlying value. This herd behavior can push stock prices to unsustainable heights, leading to bubbles that inevitably burst. For instance, during the dot-com bubble, many investors purchased tech stocks merely because other people were doing the same, resulting in valuations that were inflated.
Effects of Herd Behavior in Investing: Adopting a crowd-following strategy can lead to purchasing at peak prices and selling at lower values, causing disappointing returns. When the market bubble collapses, those who followed the majority typically suffer major financial losses. Additionally, herding can cause you to deviate from the strategies that you understand well and are already working in your favor.
Methods to Prevent Herding Bias: Focus on the intrinsic value of investments rather than market trends or popular opinion. If you know that news stations, social media websites, or other media outlets affect your ability to make prudent decisions, be honest with yourself and limit your interactions with them.
Please Note: The herding bias can be particularly strong. It’s difficult not to get swept up in worry especially during times of economic crisis. Brushing up on the history of stock market crashes can help you remain more objective and resist the pull of the masses. History has consistently shown that the market will endure and can bounce back rather quickly even after major downturns like the Great Recession and the COVID-19 pandemic.1
5) Loss Aversion Bias
Loss aversion bias describes the inclination of investors to prioritize avoiding losses over achieving similar gains. This often results in overly cautious investment approaches.Here’s the psychology behind loss aversion:
The Psychology of Loss Aversion: Investors tend to experience the discomfort of losses more intensely than the satisfaction of gains, prompting them to adopt risk-averse strategies. This aversion to loss can cause investors to avoid necessary risks, potentially missing out on higher returns. For example, an investor might hold onto cash rather than investing in stocks due to fear of potential losses, even though stocks typically offer higher long-term returns.
Examples of Loss Aversion in Investment Behavior: Investors might hold onto losing investments too long, hoping to avoid realizing a loss. This behavior, known as the disposition effect, can result in a portfolio that underperforms due to holding onto depreciating assets. Additionally, investors might sell winning investments too quickly to lock in gains, missing out on further appreciation.
Techniques to Manage Loss Aversion: Set predefined rules for selling investments, such as stop-loss orders, to limit potential losses. Focus on your long-term goals and the overall performance of your portfolio rather than short-term fluctuations. Reframe losses as an inevitable part of the investment process and an opportunity to learn, improve, and strengthen your commitment to a long-term plan.
6) Hindsight Bias
Hindsight bias is the inclination to perceive events as having been predictable only after they have happened.This bias can distort an investor’s understanding of past investment performance. Here’s how hindsight bias impacts investors:
The Impact of Hindsight Bias on Investors: Investors might believe they “knew it all along” and overestimate their predictive abilities. This can quickly lead to unrealistic assessment of their ability to predict the future. For instance, after a stock market crash, an investor might claim they had anticipated the decline, even if they had no clear evidence to support this belief beforehand.
Examples of This Bias At Work: An investor might claim they always knew a particular stock would soar after it has already done so, disregarding the uncertainty at the time of the decision. Several TV personalities may also claim that they “saw it coming from a mile away” only after the fact.
Strategies to Overcome Hindsight Bias: Regularly review past decisions objectively, acknowledging both successes and mistakes. Recognize the role of chance and external factors in investment outcomes, and avoid rewriting history to fit your current narrative.
7) Representativeness Bias
Representativeness bias is the tendency to assess the likelihood of an event based on how closely it matches other events. This can lead to faulty reasoning in investment decisions. Here’s how representativeness affects investment choices:
How Representativeness Affects Investment Choices: Investors might assume a company’s future performance will mimic its past performance, ignoring other factors. For instance, investors might assume that a stock with a strong past performance will keep doing well, overlooking shifts in the company’s fundamentals or market conditions.
Examples of This Bias in Action: Believing that a stock that has consistently increased in value will continue to do so indefinitely, despite signs of an impending downturn. Another example is assuming that a small company will grow to the size of a successful large company just because they share similar traits, without analyzing the broader market and competitive landscape.
Tips to Reduce Representativeness Bias: Analyze a wide range of data, considering both qualitative and quantitative factors. Avoid making decisions based on surface similarities alone and dive deeper into the specifics of each investment. Consider multiple scenarios and outcomes, and use statistical and probabilistic analysis to inform your decisions.
8) Availability Bias
Availability bias is the tendency to depend on easily accessible information when making decisions. This can lead to an overestimation of the importance or frequency of recent events. Here’s how availability bias influences investment decisions:
The Influence of Availability Bias on Investment Decisions: Investors might give undue weight to recent news or high-profile events, skewing their judgment. For example, after hearing about a company’s recent success in the media, an investor might overestimate the likelihood of continued success without considering potential risks or challenges.
Real-World Examples: After a market crash, investors might become overly fearful and avoid stocks, even if the underlying fundamentals are sound. Conversely, during a bull market, they might become overly optimistic and take on excessive risk, believing that recent gains will continue indefinitely.
Steps to Avoid Availability Bias: Broaden your information sources to achieve a more well-rounded view of the market. Focus on long-term trends and data rather than reacting to short-term market noise. Implement a disciplined investment strategy that involves regular portfolio reviews and adjustments based on comprehensive analysis rather than recent events.
Please Note: Research has suggested that attention spans have shrunk substantially in recent times. Some experts claim that limiting your interactions with all the noise generated by your phone can help your ability to concentrate more on important tasks.2 In my personal experience as a financial advisor, I have come across people who report constantly feeling anxious due to the latest headlines. There is absolutely no shame in taking a step back from technology, in fact it may help you hedge against availability bias when investing.
9) Self-Attribution Bias
Self-attribution bias is the inclination to credit personal actions for successes and blame external factors for failures. This bias can skew an investor’s perception of their abilities. Here’s how self-attribution bias affects investment performance:
The Effect of Self-Attribution on Investment Performance: Investors might become overconfident, believing their successes are due to skill rather than circumstance. This can lead to increased risk-taking, poor decision-making, and a downslide in portfolio performance.
Examples of Self-Attribution Bias: An investor might take credit for a stock’s rise but blame market conditions for a decline. This selective attribution can prevent them from learning from their mistakes and improving their investment strategy.
Ways to Mitigate Self-Attribution Bias: Be honest about the factors contributing to both successes and failures. Seek objective feedback and regularly review your performance critically. Keeping a detailed record of your investment decisions and their outcomes can help you identify patterns and areas for improvement.
Where Can I Go To Learn Even More About Behavioral Biases In Investment-Decision Making?
If you’re interested in delving deeper into the psychology of money and investment decision-making, there are several excellent resources available:
“Thinking, Fast and Slow” by Daniel Kahneman: This groundbreaking work explores the two systems of thought that shape our decisions: the quick, instinctive System 1 and the slower, analytical System 2. Kahneman, a Nobel Prize winner, reveals how these systems drive our judgments and often lead to errors. The book provides deep insights into human cognition and offers ways to improve decision-making.
“Predictably Irrational” by Dan Ariely: Ariely’s book uncovers the hidden forces behind our irrational behaviors, showing how we consistently make illogical choices. Through fascinating experiments and stories, he demonstrates the predictable patterns in our decision-making and offers strategies to help us make better choices. This book provides a fresh take on understanding and improving the decisions we make each and every day.
“Nudge” by Richard H. Thaler and Cass R. Sunstein: Thaler and Sunstein explore the idea of “choice architecture” and how minor adjustments in the presentation of options can greatly influence our decisions. They explain how these subtle nudges can guide us toward better choices in various areas of life, from finances to health, without limiting our freedom. It’s an insightful look at how small changes can have a big impact.
“The Psychology of Money” by Morgan Housel: Housel’s book is a collection of insightful stories that delve into the behavioral side of personal finance. He argues that managing money is more about understanding human behavior and emotions than financial expertise. Housel provides enduring insights on wealth, greed, and happiness, simplifying the intricacies of financial management and making them easier to understand and relate to.
I Can Help You Handle Behavioral Biases In Investment Decision-Making
At Snowpine Wealth, we understand the challenges that behavioral biases can present in your financial journey. As a CFP® Financial Advisor, I’ve been helping people like you navigate these biases for well over a decade. By leveraging my experience and the principles of behavioral finance, we can work together to create a more objective and successful investment strategy.
Recognizing and managing biases in investment decision-making is crucial for achieving your long-term financial goals. By focusing on data-driven decisions and maintaining a disciplined approach with a financial thinking partner, you can overcome these biases and improve your financial outcomes.
If you’re ready to take control of your investments and ensure your decisions are guided by rational analysis rather than emotional biases, contact us today. Let’s work together to secure your financial future and make informed, confident investment choices. Schedule an appointment with me at a time that’s convenient for you using the button below!
Securities and advisory services offered through Commonwealth Financial Network®, Member FINRA/SIPC, a Registered Investment Advisor.Fixed insurance products and services not offered through Commonwealth Financial Network®.
Diversification does not assure a profit or protect against loss in declining markets, and diversification cannot guarantee that any objective or goal will be achieved.
